Have you seen it yet? If not, you're missing out. Nobody Wants This might not be the show everyone’s talking about just yet, but it should be. And as someone who lives and breathes casting, I can tell you—the casting in this series is absolutely on point.
Each actor brings something unique to the screen, and it’s one of the main reasons this show stands out. Let’s break down the key players who make Nobody Wants This the gem that it is.
Justine Lupe-Schomp: A Quiet Powerhouse
If you’re not already familiar with Justine Lupe-Schomp, you will be after this. She’s been brilliant in Succession and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, but this role really shows off her range. Justine grew up in Denver and has some serious theatre roots—her grandmother even has a theatre named after her, and you can see that deep connection to the craft in every scene.
Her performance here? Subtle, strong, funny and completely engaging. She brings a layered, authentic energy to the character that’s hard to look away from. It’s clear why the casting team chose her—no one else could have done this role justice.
And the relationship between these two characters of Morgan and Sasha is something that we really haven't seen before.
Kristen Bell: A Stunning "Glow Up"
Is it just me, or, did Kirsten have a massive glow up! She looks more gorgeous than I remember?
Now, Kristen Bell has always been great, but this show? She steps away from the quirky roles we’ve known her for and shows a more complex, emotional side. It’s a real pleasure to watch her in this.
The chemistry between her and the other actors, especially Justine Lupe-Schomp and Adam Brody, is off the charts. She brings such depth to her character—it’s Kristen Bell, but with a fresh edge.
BEST KISS EVER!
Adam Brody: Breaking the Rom-Com Mould
You probably remember him as the charming guy from The O.C., but in Nobody Wants This, he’s stepping away from the usual rom-com "loser" trope. His character is kind, steady, and genuinely really likeable—exactly the kind of role we don’t see enough of these days.
It’s so refreshing to watch a male character who isn’t just a narcissist or a bumbling fool. Brody’s character is a decent guy, bringing a sense of stability and warmth that we really need in storytelling right now. This isn’t about a guy chasing after the female lead; it’s about a solid, relatable man who actually adds to the narrative.
Honestly, this casting choice is a huge win. Adam nails it by balancing the emotional highs and lows of the show, delivering a performance that feels grounded and real. In a world where male characters are often depicted as flawed or self-absorbed, Brody’s character is a reminder that there are genuinely good men out there.
It’s a fantastic shift in how we can write male roles—showing vulnerability and decency without falling into tired clichés.
Timothy Simons: Playing to His Strengths
And then there’s Timothy Simons. If you’ve seen Veep, you know how hilarious he is—and in Nobody Wants This, the writing plays directly to his strengths. His character is woven into the show with such sharpness that it feels like it was written just for him.
Simons is absolutely hilarious here, but it’s not just about the comedy. He brings an emotional depth to his role that adds so much richness to the show. It’s beautifully done, and it’s another example of how spot-on the casting is.
The Power of Perfect Casting & GREAT WRITING.
What really stands out about Nobody Wants This is how well these actors work together. The chemistry is undeniable, and from my experience in casting, I can tell you that’s not easy to achieve. It takes the right people in the right roles to create this kind of magic on screen, and this show nails it.
If you haven’t watched it yet, give it a go.
The casting alone is worth the watch!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Interested in learning more about how we can help cast your next project? Reach out to us at, Brock Casting Services and discover how we can bring your vision to life with Queensland’s finest talent.
Comments